In AUSTIN and throughout Texas

Dismissal of Charges in Austin Yogurt Shop Murders

There are certain notorious crimes that leave a lasting impact even on the people that only read about the violence in the newspaper or see it on the news. Perhaps a high-profile celebrity gets killed and the details are fodder for the tabloids for months. Or, maybe the crime that is committed is done so against the most innocent and harmless among us, and the violence leaves everyone asking how such an act could occur.

Nearly eighteen years ago, the city of Austin was rocked by such a crime with the murders of four teenage girls at a I Can't Believe It's Yogurt Shop in North Austin. Two young men, Michael Scott and Robert Springsteen confessed to the crimes eight years later, but ten years they spent in jail may end up being the totality of their punishment with the admission of new DNA evidence.

Scott and Springsteen were released from jail in June 2009, under the order of State District Judge Mike Lynch, while awaiting a re-trial in light of new evidence and confessions that may have been coerced. The key issue? Investigators were now able to analyze DNA samples in ways that weren't possible nearly two decades ago.

DNA discovered in one of the yogurt shop victims does not match that of Scott or Springsteen, and today prosecutors moved to dismiss the charges against the two men until it can be determined the owner of the mystery genetic material. Prosecutors had hoped to obtain a continuance in the case while further DNA testing was done. When Judge Lynch made it clear that the trial must move forward, prosecutors decided the best option was hopefully to start over with a new trial at a later date.

As Travis County District Attorney Rosemary Lehmberg shared in a statement, "I believe it is the best legal and strategic course to take and is the one that leaves us in the best possible posture to ultimately retry both Springsteen and Scott."

As is shown by the state's case against Scott and Springsteen, criminal cases are often complex and can turn on the smallest piece of evidence. If you are facing serious criminal charges, you need an experienced criminal defense attorney to represent you through the legal maze. Please contact the law offices of Bertolino LLP in Austin, Houston, or San Antonio and let's see if we can help you.

Categories: Articles

Attorney Tony R. Bertolino is the Managing Partner with Bertolino LLP. Our Law Firm has been able to help people across the state of Texas through our offices in Austin, Houston and San Antonio. If you need an experienced lawyer to represent you, contact Bertolino LLP today.

Super Lawyers Rising Star American Bar Association Defending Liberty Pursuing Justice State Bar of Texas Pro Bono College Super Lawyers New York State Bar Association Houston Bar Association Austin Bar Association American Center for Law and Justice Law Firm 500 10.0Tony Ray Bertolino

Tell us about your legal matter

yes I have read the disclaimer